A league of their own... - Instablogs
A league of their own...
Mayuri Majumdar , Kolkata: Mar 24 2008
Made Popular Mar 25 2008
India :

A league of their own...
This is a story of a woman who identified herself as one. The society wouldn’t let her be but she fought and fought till she was successful. We call their class as “Hijras” and outcast them. How easy is it for them to tolerate what the society is burdening them with- a feeling of non-belongingness, a feeling of difference and to top it all, exploitation and more of it.

In the culture of the Indian subcontinent a hijra is usually considered a member of “the third sex” — neither man nor woman. Most are physically male or intersex, but some are female. Hijras usually refer to themselves as female at the language level, and usually dress as women. Becoming a hijra is a process of socialization into a “hijra family” through a relationship characterised as chela “student” to guru “teacher”, leading to a gradual assumption of femininity. Typically each guru lives with at least five chelas; her chelas assume her surname and are considered part of her lineage. Chelas are expected to give their income to their guru, who manages the household. Hijra families are close knit communities, which often have their own houses.
A league of their own...
Lakshmi Narayan Tripathi is one such woman. A woman who found herself embedded in body not her own. She went on to discover herself as a woman and now she is the woman with courage and an individuality of her own. A professional Bharatnatyam dancer, Laxmi started learning the dance form when she was 12 years old. From dance bars to being a hijda, she is now the proud owner of a chain of 9 Bharatnatyam dance schools in Mumbai. Today Laxmi also focuses her time towards social activities. She says, “People used to call me a hijra for years, and because they did I didn’t want to know about hijras. Eventually, the things you evade, confront you. And now I’m here.” The community introduced Laxmi to the freedoms of living with people similar to her. “How did I know that I was a hijra?” she mulls. “I don’t know. I asked myself that. I tried to run away, but I kept returning. Even now, it’s a question that’s on my mind 24 hours. But do I want to go back (to the mainstream)? No! My soul won’t allow it.”

I read her story somewhere on the net and felt good that someone is standing up for justice. A justice towards the self, a justice towards the heart and soul. While Lakshmi goes on to live with full confidence, I wonder how many people would make fun of her and her group and try to make them realize that they do not fit in the society.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
It is just stupid to think that people make fun of them for what they are. If the Community itself lives in their own world without bothering us, why should we go ahead and bother them by passing remarks which are insane. A ’hijra’ walking on a street would never hit back at your and call u a ’mard’ or ’aurat’ so why should we do otherwise. The uneducated lot can understandably get mused by them, but at least the ones who are educated should give them their own breathing space.
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
Well, Atul, I have seen people make fun of them even if they aren’t bothering them. Leave out making fun, seeing them with raised eyes, passing comments is another aspect as well. I mean if someone goes out on the road and is looked with raised eyebrows how will he feel?
2 Stars
I realized that little flaw in my comment the moment I submitted it Mayuri:)

It is actually true that even if they don’t interact with anybody, they still have to bear the blunt. It’s always a possibility that someone or the other would come out with cheap words for them regardless of they saying anything.

Wonder what education teaches people in this country. Why cant those poor people have their own freedom just as we do.
3 Stars
Kalpana Tripathi
Mumbai, Allahabad, India
When these people are happy in their worlds then let them live their life happily, they are already cursed by god and nature. They are earning by themselves and trying to make their own niche, they are not snatching anything from you people then why these comments and making fun of them. They are as normal as anybody else, Government should try to make some effort and work for them and their proper living.
2 Stars
Well, I don’t see Mayuri, nor Did I make Fun of them in these Comments. I request you to read the comments a little more carefully Kalpana.

Our Legal System does not define them as different or challenged individuals which restricts the govt. from offering any kind of help. But yes provisions must be made against people who taunt them; should be subject to defamation charges.
2 Stars
Rajesh
Mumbai, India
hi Mayuri,

You know what i think there are more than 60% of Indians who dont know the meaning of democracy. They even dont know there rights so u tell me how will they know about others rights and respect them?
You know 1st of all Hijras are not cursed its been more than 300 years these communities exists but people not trying to understand or accept them. This is also a community like male or female and we should have to accept them as it is.
And about harrasing them there are people who harrases them... As i said these are the different community of Harrasers according to me. You Know this community will harasse you if you want bring some change in the society. Look into the History..All social reformers have faced the same problem... whenever they have tried to bring the change in the system from bad to good.
So i think People really need to change there perspetive to look at the Hijaras. They are normal human being but its the third generation.
And they fit on this planet there is no society.. We have created the Society and if we are not ready to accept them.. Then we are not humans we are animals. What say...?
2 Stars
A very relevant question has been raised and you should be congratulated for that Mayuri. It is saddening to see people ostracising a class of people simply because of something they could never help! One should respect them for their individuality, but they in turn should also assume a normal life. When they enter in a rather unwanted and obscene fashion into family functions to ask for money, they make themselves the butt of all humiliation. If such activities are expected to stop then they in turn should also assume a better profession than to get money simply because they belong to a certain gender or neither one of them.
2 Stars
So how is it that you expect them to make money Somya...When there is no social acceptance for them anywhere, so what else can they do...It is not because they accept their identity and choose that way of making money. Our Society has singulated them, they haven’t singulated themselves from the society.

They want to live as normal human beings but we don’t allow them to. Lakshmi Narayan Tripathi was constantly made aware that she was a Hijra and she kept running away from the fact! Who singulated who here proves the point...No Hard feelings Somya!
2 Stars
Kalpana Tripathi
Mumbai, Allahabad, India
@atul I have not said anything on your comment buddy, I just talked about whole human society who consider them a mocking piece. Well, you said that they dont fall in the category of as different or challenged individuals but can you tell what aids they are getting from our government. Each and every place they get humiliated.

@rajesh They are not a different community and born only to normal man and woman, after that they switch to their community. These peoples are born due to chromosomal defects and they are just like us with some extra X or less X.
2 Stars
Thats what I exactly mentioned Kalpana, there isn’t a provision in our constitution which defines them as categorically different thus they don’t derive any immediate benefits from the same but yes provisions should be made for punishing people who defame them.
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
@ Atul
I ask you to read my article once again. Lakshmi is a ”hijra” and she is earning money by teaching dance. And Lakshmi kept running away from the fact but at last she was the one who accepted herself as she is. I mean i shudder with fear when I imagine myself feeling like a woman and embedded in a man’s body.

And things won’t change. Educated people tease them all the while. I was in auto today and there was a hijra passing by, the auto driver smiled and passed a comment. Also did my co-passengers( Kolkata has a shuttle auto system). I felt so bad.
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
I do not know if anybody has ever seen Channel V’s Get Gorgeous. Well, in the final episode, Lakshmi was called by the producers to give the contestants a pep talk and make them realize their womanhood and be proud of them. I felt that as a brilliant step on the part of the producers and planners.
1 Stars
That’s a case of maximum acceptance Mayuri...One in a million can achieve what she has...But the rest still bear the blunt as I mentioned in my first comment. I wish I saw that episode on Channel V.

Answer me on this then… How many of your colleagues would tolerate a Hijra being your boss, other than u of course...Lakshmi chose a profession where a Hijra can think of recognition, but the other doors are absolutely closed, unless the govt. makes some mandatory provisions. Thus, it is us who close the doors on them not them who close the doors on themselves.
2 Stars
@Atul
I agree with you mate. Till the government makes mandatory provisions for Transsexuals to be adopted into the mainstream of the Indian society, it will be very difficult days for the transsexuals. You will be stunned to know that a person can kill a transsexual and go scot-free since the case will not hold in the Indian court of law as the IPC does not even recognize transsexuals as a living class of people. So there you are, a live example of how the system works against these opressed class of people.
1 Stars
Gud u didn’t use dude Jay!!otherwise that appreciation would have been really disappointing...Lol!
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
That is what I am perplexed about. Why can’t ”we” accept it? They have done so, which is more difficult; then why can’t we? And plus, who are we to judge someone for his/her sexuality? Good old qualities do not hold any value? I am not here to change the world. This is my small attempt to just throw some light on this matter. I would be happy if someone’s opinion changes. If somebody vows to stick to his/ her opinion, I am helpless. Well, if the govt makes some mandatory rules, their conditions will further deteriorate. They require social equality. Some provision would further outcast them. The citizens would never agree to something like this.
2 Stars
@Mayuri
Please understand that India is a still stuck up with prejudices with intercaste marriages itself being taboo, let alone inter-religion marriages. So do you think that such a society can adopt the ”hijra’s” whom the Indian law itself hasn’t yet recognized. I agree that you want people to change. But they won’t change just like that. They need to be pushed and prodded to change, which is why i mentioned the need for the Indian government to frame strict legislations. I am sorry Mayuri, you seem to be caught up in a world where absolute equality prevails, which unfortunately is not the case at the moment and may never be in the future also.
2 Stars
At least a ray of hope for them Mayuri...otherwise u, me and all of us have known this country for long!! They need these provisions more than the low caste, the Tribes or the minorities... They find a kind of relief in their secluded world and with a little bit of aid from the govt. they could do better in their limited sphere.

Otherwise this country would never allow them to be entertained as normal human beings...I feel like taking refuge in your words today...I feel ashamed of being an Indian, considering the depleted state of these Hijras.

If I talk like this openly may be they dub me as one too... feel safer in jotting down my thoughts amongst the people of the Ib Community! Maybe a few of us together could do something that could inflict a social change. Reformation would be to big a word, atleast a change of thoughts. Cheers people!
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
I do not think that my country is that of a socially equal one. But my point is if they are treated as minorities or something alike, they wouldn’t only like it. It would be all the more difficult, juggling with two parties disagreeing on the same point.
2 Stars
@mayuri
But if they want to be integrated into the Indian social strata, they need to be treated as minorities. With the prevailing situation, don’t you think it would be better for them to be minorities than being absolutely insignificant?
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
See I think so, you think so. But I doubt if they would think alike. It is evident from Lakshmi’s words and life that she wanted to be just like any of us. Ok, forget about the hijras, I have seen many others. You must have heard and seen Bobby Darling. I know the govt rules would make them heard but will that satisfy their will of equality? I do not have any problems with the idea you have suggested but thinking from their perspective, I have written what I felt.
2 Stars
@mayuri
Yes, but how can they become integrated into the society without any help. Even if they feel bad they have to take what is given to them, atleast at this given point of time. If they don’t get minority status, they will always be harrassed and will never make it to mainstream society. For example, take a look at the various backward castes of India, and how they have risen slowly because of certain reservations given to them. Similarly if the transsexuals are given a few privileges, they will slowly become a part of the Indian society. And this is precisely what i am trying to say in all my posts on this topic. A perfect case of something is better than nothing.
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
I accept your suggestions with full praise. But I am sure that even if they are given some provision, they will never be stopped from being jeered at. India’s mental make-up is a staunch one and wouldn’t change easily!
Add your Comment